"I was wrong about Trump."
This op-ed by M.B. Mathews ran in the American Thinker in 2022 and got virtually no play. It should have. It’s a must read. I published it back then and it is one of my MOST READ POSTS of all time.
I know many people inflicted with TDS who STILL say the same things about President Trump today and I am glad M.B. Mathews had the courage to admit he was wrong! I wish more people were that honest and humble!
I was wrong about Trump
By M.B. Mathews
“I recently wrote a column about why I believed Trump should not run for President. I was wrong. I allowed my distaste for Trump’s personality to override his virtues, which are considerable.
Some people want Trump without his vices. I was among them -- until yesterday, when I watched and listened to Tom Klingenstein’s speech titled “Trump’s virtues.” It was masterful and shamed me that I did not make the distinction between Trump's character and his virtues, the former being deeply flawed, the latter being almost perfect.
I need to man up in my defense of the President's virtues. The speech was among the most pointed I have heard and deserves some exposure. Klingenstein says:
Other Republicans say some version of “I like Trump policies but I don’t like the rest of him.” This gets it almost backwards. Although Trump advanced many important policies, it is the 'rest of him' that contains the virtue that inspires the movement… Trump was born for the current crisis, a life and death struggle against a totalitarian enemy I call woke communism... that control all the cultural and economic powers in America…
Trump revealed, not caused, the divide in this country. In war, you must make a stand… Trump is a manly man... traditional manhood, even when flawed, is absolutely essential… Trump plays to win... There are no clean hands in a fistfight…Trump is unreservedly, unquestionably pro-America… Trump is a refreshing break from the guilt and self-loathing that marks our age…
It is anti-Americanism that makes so many of us very angry: The Left have trashed America's Founding and her history to the point where some believe it virtuous to hate America. Rather than advocating forgiveness for sins, the Left are advocating hair shirts, self-flagellation, and perpetual guilt. It is un-American and certainly un-Christian.
Trump thinks we can vanquish all comers if we just put our minds to it, and he's right… Courage never demands perfection… Trump over and over said exactly what political correctness prohibits one from saying... Trump said Haiti is a shithole and that representative Maxine Waters has a low IQ. These were not racist lies. They were uncouth, politically incorrect observations that most of us would agree with but would not dare say.
In 2016, we loved Trump for his outspokenness. But many seem to have changed their minds without cause; Trump is the same today as he was before. The very things we disdain today are the things that made him the man for our time.
From morning to night, we were told that Trump is a racist. But endless repetition does not make it true. It isn’t. Trump’s contempt for political correctness showed patriotic Americans that its ever-tightening grip could be loosened... It is difficult to overestimate the significance of Trump’s fight against political correctness, a fight which most Republicans are reluctant to engage… Trump treated the woke media with the same contempt he treated political correctness, provoking their outrage and revealing their utter corruption... it must be defeated.
I take back my unwillingness to engage Trump on his own terms. It is the Left, not we, who are politically correct. They are the ones restricting speech, cancelling and censoring, not we on the Right.
Unlike most politicians, when Trump sees a problem, he goes out and fixes it. He fixed our porous borders. He moved our Israeli embassy to Jerusalem after decades of inaction. He eliminated hate-America critical race theory in his administrative agency. He achieved energy independence and much, much more.
His accomplishments far outweigh his personality quirks. No other president did so much in so little time.
Trump smoked rats out of hiding places. Because of Trump we know our intelligence agencies are corrupt. We know also that the mainstream media is not just biased, that it is the propaganda arm of the Democratic party.
Had it not been for the vehement and irrational hatred of Trump, we never would have discovered that our own security and intelligence structures are compromised. I blame Never Trumpers for corrupting these Agencies. This unprecedented breach of the very security of this nation is unprecedented and deeply dangerous, leaving us open to the espionage of courtesans who prey on politicians who think with their private parts.
A large part of Trump’s appeal was that he was a bona fide outsider. He distrusted the experts who believe they knew better than the average American how to run the country. This distrust was appealing to Trump’s base who believed, and with good reason, that is the experts who created the despotic mess in which we find ourselves.
We always knew but never had anyone champion that we, not the Swamp, knew better how to manage our money, our time, our personal lives, our resources and our families. In their authoritarian mindsets, the Left wanted to take over all these very personal, uniquely American functions and replace it with governmental overreach. They nearly got their wish, had it not been for COVID's home zoom classes where we found out that very young children are being sexualized, perverted, deliberately alienated from their parents and taught to hate America and white people.
…They know that Republicans will lose all further elections until they get to the bottom of the last one.
This most sensitive area of politics is a disaster. I believe the election was stolen and millions of others do. We now have evidence from many quarters that this is so. It cannot be permitted a repeat or there will be severe repercussions that will dwarf the current ones.
Some will say that Trump is a bad man and that disqualifies him. I do not think Trump is a bad man, but for those who do I remind them that a bad man in some circumstances can be a good president. If you’re dying of thirst and there is only one person offering you water, you accept the water gratefully without much concern for the character of your rescuer.
We wanted Trump not only to fix things; we wanted him to be perfect while doing it. That is unrealistic in the average family, the average relationship, the average business and the average political or cultural milieu. Yet some of us wanted Trump to be perfect enough to invite to tea. He is not that man. But he is the man for our tumultuous times.
This enumeration of Trump’s virtues does not fully capture his uncommon courage and firmness of purpose. Trump is the most towering political figure in living memory… Trump inspired a movement. If properly deployed this movement might challenge the woke-comms, and God willing, save the country.
These very things are what the Left hate, yet it is not their favor we need to care about. They will not embrace anyone on the Republican ticket and certainly not one they cannot bully. We need to stop worrying about acceptance of our candidates by the Left or they will have won.
Republicans, however, should not forget that it is his support and the spirit they embrace that have become the life force of the Republican party. Among the talked-about alternatives to Trump I have not yet seen anyone who possesses or even understands Trump’s virtues. Nor have I seen anyone with his backbone and fortitude. One does not appreciate the strength of relentless gale-force winds until one is in the eye of the storm.
…which is exactly where Trump and we are at this moment. We have to prepare for the gale-force winds we will encounter. To not do this is to ignore the lessons of the recent past and it will be forever to our sorrow to ignore them.
His virtue must be the standard by which we judge other candidates.
Amen and amen. We don't have to like his personality but his virtues far outweigh it. I humbly stand corrected and offer my mea culpa.”
How did President Trump respond to this when it was written?
“Wow! What a great honor to have this written about me. We must Save America, and will! Thank you, M.B.”
That’s my President!
For all the noise, outrage, and endless repetition of the same tired attacks on President Trump, the fundamental truth hasn’t changed: the case against Trump still rests far more on emotion than evidence. What some dismissively call “Trump Derangement Syndrome” reflects, at its core, a refusal to confront reality with intellectual honesty.
History does not judge presidents by personality; it judges them by results. And by that standard, Trump’s record on behalf of the American people remains substantial, consequential, and difficult to refute.
Those still clinging to the same objections in 2026 are, in many ways, where M.B. Mathews once was: focused on Trump’s flaws while overlooking the scale of his effectiveness - and willfully ignoring the very reasons that God has saved Trump thus far - to save us from ourselves. As Mathews ultimately recognized, leadership in turbulent times is not about perfection, but about resolve, clarity, and the willingness to confront entrenched power.
Disagreement, of course, is healthy. But there is a difference between disagreement and willful blindness. At some point, intellectual honesty requires an act of humility: a willingness to say, plainly and without qualification: “I was wrong about Trump.”
If you value my work, please consider making a donation. This is my full time job and my mission is to wade through the noise and bring you the truth.
My work is free for all but supported by donations from many generous readers. Thank you to all who have donated in the past. I truly appreciate you!
How can you donate? In many ways: You can fund me by becoming a paid subscriber on Substack, donate by credit or debit card here or by Cash App at $TierneyRealNews, send me a check to Peggy Tierney, PO Box 242, Spooner, Wisconsin 54801- or just send me a note or a card! I love hearing from you.
If you use the Substack app to read my newsletters - please make sure you check your settings so that you receive it BOTH by email and in the app. I don’t want you to miss a newsletter!
You can always email me at peggy@TierneyRealNewsNetwork.com. Please follow me on Telegram at t.me/TierneyRealNews. Follow me on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100079025148615. Or you can find me on Truth Social @MaggiePeggy123.
For whatever reasons, I never became squeamish about my total enthusiastic support for Donald J. Trump to be President once I heard him speak several times in mid-2016. I voted for Cruz in the primary that year because I foolishly thought that Trump's candidacy was merely a PR stunt. But as he racked up primary wins across the US (including my own blue Mid Atlantic state) I was "forced" to pay attention.
I had just retired from almost 40 years working at the same company, and was not paying sufficient attention to politics, having mentally "surrendered" to the inevitability of yet another Democrat-manipulated win after seeing two miserably-run Republican attempts (in 2008 and 2012) go down in flames against an obvious liar and fraud of a man who seemed to command an inexplicable persuasive power over the press and a majority of the populace.
But shame on me. So I started listening to both Trump's speeches and tweets and Rush Limbaugh's growing affinity for Trump. By November I was solidly on the Trump Train, attracted by his political incorrectness and tell-it-like-it-is brash New York directness. I liked 98% of his policies (can't recall the ones in 2016 that I thought were unfavorable) and since then, despite the media's record-setting negative bias and dishonest reporting about the man, have only strengthened my now-rock-solid and unwavering support.
I sometimes, cringe over some things he says or memes he posts. However these acts are far outweigbed by his willingness to do whatever is right no matter the political cost. Current example is the Iran situation and his willingness to go ahead in an election year. Let us all hope that people wise up and fully support the republicans in the next election. I know they seem to be do nothings and Rhinos, but they are better than electing democrats as Trump will definitely be impeached if the Dems get the majority. People please do not bite off your nose to spite your face. He is the biggest cheerleader for this country that this country has ever had. Also he has an uncanny ability to see things and predict things that end up coming to fruition. He always seems to be right in then end.